Many people grew up with Kinder Surprise – a simple, yet brilliant product consisting of a chocolate egg housing a surprise toy inside that was invented back in 1974.
If you live in the US, however, you simply can’t put your hands on this exhilarating little item because of a regulatory ban. The ban far precedes the invention of the toy/chocolate combo, making it illegal in the Land of the Free ever since its inception. However, a shopping address in the UK or Germany can help you have them shipped to your address.
The ban is the result of the 1938 Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. As per this regulatory framework, “non-nutritive” objects can’t be embedded in food.
Kinder Surprise consists of a plastic toy-holding capsule that is completely encased by the chocolate shell. The regulation suggests that such a design poses a significant choking hazard.
Kinder Joy wasn’t specifically created for the US market even though it happened to solve the ban problem. It was originally launched in 2001 in Italy and was called Kinder Merendero. Targeting markets like the Middle East, India, and parts of Africa, it was designed to withstand transportation and storage in hot climate countries.
The Kinder Joy egg consists of two separate halves, one containing the toy and the other one – a chocolate treat. That way, the cocoa-flavored cream filling sits in a sealed plastic half that's much more heat-stable than a solid chocolate shell. It is also more shelf-stable than chocolate in warm conditions.
This design also happened to comply with US regulations, and the product was allowed on the local market in 2018.
Anyone who has ever had a Kinder Surprise egg, however, will tell you that Kinder Joy simply doesn’t deliver the same anticipation and fun of cracking the chocolate and fishing out the plastic toy capsule inside.
| Kinder Surprise | Kinder Joy | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Italy, 1974 | Italy, 2001 |
| Structure |
Whole chocolate egg toy capsule inside chocolate |
Two separate halves cream + toy in own compartment |
| Toy placement |
Embedded inside fully enclosed in chocolate |
Physically separate own sealed half of the egg |
| Chocolate |
Solid chocolate shell milk + white chocolate layers |
Cocoa-flavored cream not a solid chocolate shell |
| US status |
FDA non-nutritive object rule – toy hidden in food |
Toy not in contact with food – complies with FDA rules |
| Available in | Europe, Canada, 100+ countries | US, Europe & worldwide |
For anyone who grew up with Kinder Surprise, Kinder Joy is a perfectly enjoyable treat; however, the experience is just not the same. A few key differences explain why fans of the original remain loyal:
Half the fun of Kinder Surprise is the egg itself. Cracking through the chocolate shell to find the yellow capsule inside is a ritual that Kinder Joy's snap-open plastic design simply can't replicate. The tactile, slightly messy process of getting to the toy is part of the appeal.
Kinder Surprise has a long tradition of intricate, collectable miniatures – tiny hand-assembled figurines, puzzles, and themed series that have developed a dedicated collector community. Kinder Joy toys, while fun, tend to be simpler and less collectable by design.
Kinder Surprise is produced to European confectionery standards, using the brand's signature combination of milk and white chocolate. Kinder Joy replaces the chocolate shell with a cocoa-flavored cream – a practical solution for hot climates that results in a noticeably different taste and texture for chocolate purists.
For many European adults, Kinder Surprise is bound up in childhood memories in a way that no reformulated version can fully match.
Ferrero has made limited-edition collaborations a core part of the Kinder Joy strategy, regularly partnering with major entertainment franchises to release collectable toy series. Some of the most sought-after editions include:
The regional nature of these drops is part of what makes them so collectable — an edition available in Germany may never reach US shelves, and vice versa. Parcel forwarding makes it possible to get hold of whichever edition isn't available in your market.
Obviously the Kinder Surprise situation in the US is no bueno. So, what options do you have if you’d like to experience the original Kinder Surprise fun?
Here’s an approach that we’d recommend if you want to buy Kinder Surprise eggs for personal use in the US:
Keep in mind that the solution is only suitable for personal use purchases. You’ll still be importing an item in the US at your own risk. Please familiarize yourself with local regulations before moving on to buying Kinder Surprise eggs.
Kinder Joy is always an option, but the authentic nostalgia that Kinder Surprise brings simply can’t be replaced.
Kinder Surprise eggs can be bought legally in more than 170 countries across the world. Parcel forwarding gives you access to many of these markets, regardless of the US ban on the fun chocolate eggs.
Would you like to have the occasional delectable treat? Sign up for a German or a UK address with forward2me and enjoy European-style Kinder Surprise eggs for personal use.
If you’re just getting started and you don’t know where to look for European goods, browse our European retailers list in the forward2me Shopping Center or get in touch with us to have your questions answered.
Banned since 1938
Legal & sold widely 
.png "Rihanna: From Pop Superstar to Business Mogul and Self-Made Billionaire")
